Granted, it is doubtful that Wesley would be a WWE fan, but it seems like an adequate description of the argument I am about to share.
Came across this gem as I began to reread Randy Maddox’s modern classic Responsible Grace in hopes that it will spark ideas as I begin to write my ordination papers. For Methodists, there is probably no better broad interpretation of Wesley’s whole project than this monograph. For non-Methodists, it is important for its contributions to practical theology and for its suggestions (via Wesleyan soteriology) toward healing the Orthodox-Catholic rift.
This particular passage comes during a discussion of Wesley’s view of Scripture. For Papa John, it was important that any text be interpreted within the structure and thrust of the whole Bible. To defend a devilish doctrine – like predestination – on Scriptural grounds was, for Wesley, an affront to the whole testimony of the Bible. Predestination, he says,
destroys all His attributes at once. It overturns both his justice, mercy and truth. Yea, it represents the most Holy God as worse than the devil…. But you say you will ‘prove it by Scripture’. Hold! What will you prove by Scripture? That God is worse than the devil? It cannot be. Whatever that Scripture proves, it never can prove this….There are many Scriptures the true sense whereof neither you or I shall know till death is swallowed up in victory. But this I know, better it were such say it had no sense at all than to say it had such a sense as this….No Scripture can mean that God is not love, or that his mercy is not over all this works. (“Free Grace,” quoted in Maddox, 39.)
Calvinism has been resurgent lately (and not the friendly, graceful Barthian version). I’m not sure why, except perhaps that in an age of sloganeering and polarization, there are folks attracted to strong convictions of whatever sort, regardless of theological merit. Of course, hardcore Calvinists will say that we Arminians lean towards works righteousness or universalism. But, with Wesley, I would affirm that double predestination turns the God of the Bible into an unrecognizable tyrant.
The full text of the above sermon is available here.